218-824-6444   |    info@prairiebay.com
Contact Us


Printable Dinner Menu

    Sample, Share and Salads

    • Lobster Salad Tostada$11.50

      3 Crisps, Avocado, Cilantro, Blood Orange Syrup

    • Sous Chef's Soup $6.00

      Created Daily for the NEXT Day! Bowl - $6 and Cup - $3.5

    • Jack Pine Beer Battered Onion Rings$10.00

    • Coconut Fried Shrimp "Fondue"$14.00

      5 Prawns, Coconut Milk-Pineapple Sauce, Lime

    • B.Y.O.B. (Build your own Bruschetta for 2)$16.75

      Everyone's Favorite! Roasted Garlic Toast, Fresh Made Condiments. Spicy Sundried Tomato Jam, Caramelized Onions, Roasted Garlic Clove, Basil Pesto, E.V.O.O., Smoked Tomato Coulis, Marinated Portobella Mushrooms, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Bell Peppers, Shaved Parmesan (GF)

    • Blackened Ahi Tuna & Wilted Spinach Salad$14.90

      Fairbault Blue Cheese, Fried Onions, Spicy Brown Sugar Dressing

    • St. Mathias Farm Roasted Beet Salad$10.50

      Stickney Hill Chevre, E.V.O.O., Seasonal Greens, Lakes Shore Honey Dressing $10.5 Whole $7 Side (GF)

    • Prairie Bay Chopped Wedge Salad$9.00

      Grilled Chicken, Pear, Blue Cheese, Onion, Bacon, Scallion, Iceberg $9 Whole $5 Side (GF)

    • Lamb & Goat Cheese Stuffed Pepper$10.00

      Four Piquillo Peppers, Saffron Aioli

    • Ahi Tuna Sashimi Taco Crisp$10.00

      Spring Roll Pastry, Cilantro, Jicama Slaw, Sriracha, Sesame Ginger

    Meat and Potatoes

    All Served with our Famous Chevre Scalloped Potatoes

    • Whisky Smoked Beef Brisket$18.50

      Slow Braised with Caramelized Sweet Potato Puree, Brussel Sprouts

    • "Mad Thai"$26.00

      Choice of: Shrimp, Chicken, Beef, Veggies, Ahi, Walleye, or Pork Tenderloin Completed with Rice Noodles, Cilantro, Spicy Curry, Bok Choy and Peanut Sauce

    • Hazelnut Crusted Walleye$25.00

      Green Grapes, Sage Raisin Noisette and Caramelized Sweet Potato Puree

    • Cherrywood Smoked Breast of Duck$25.00

      Balsamic Onions, Beer Cheese Risotto, Brussel Sprouts, Toasted Pumpkin Seeds

    • 12 oz. Sugar-Seared New York Steak$29.00

      Chevre Scalloped Potatoes, Dried Cherry Reduction

    • Ancho Chile Grilled Steak Adobo$25.00

      6 oz. Medallions, Garlic Crushed New Potatoes

    Wood-Fired Pizzas

    Hand-Rolled Daily,Thin Crisp Crusts, the Freshest Ingredients! (Take and Bake Now Available) Gluten Free Crust Available - $15.99

    • Blue Cheese Roasted Grape and Fig$15.99

      Great with a Heavy Red Wine

    • Chicken Apple Honey Brie$15.99

      The Perfect Combination

    • Forest Mushroom Chevre$15.99

      Caramelized Onions, Fresh Herbs

    • Thai Shrimp Curry$15.99

      Coconut Milk Curry, Bok Choy, Cilantro, Toasted Peanuts

    • My Big Fat Greek Pizza$15.99

      Artichoke, Kalamata Olives, Peppers, Sundried Tomatoes, Feta Cheese

    • Classic American Pepporoni and Sausage$15.99

      The Best Around

    • Spanish Pie$15.99

      Chorizo, Piquillo Peppers, Green Olives, Manchego, Saffron Aioli

    • Peppe' Le Pew$15.99

      Andouille, Peppadew, Gorganzola, Truffle Oil

    • Lamb Meatball & Roasted Garlic$15.99

      Chiffonade Mint, Goat Cheese, Red Onion

    • The Chef Za$15.99

      Brussel Sprouts, Golden Raisins, Smoked Bacon, MN Blue Cheese

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch$15.99

      Katie's Secret Recipe, Green Onions, Garlic

    • Clam Chowder$15.99

      Sea Clams, White Wine Garlic Thyme Cream, Potato, Bacon

    3 Tacos

      Gourmet Sandwiches

      Gluten Free Bread and Buns Available Upon Request

      • Reuban 2.0$13.75

        House-Braised Corn Beef Brisket, Thick-Toast Rye, Bold 2000 Island Dressing, Sauerkraut, Swiss Fondue

      • Local Grass-Fed Patty Melt$13.50

        Stonebridge and Hollister Family Farms, Swiss, Caramelized Onions, Roasted Peppers, Rye Toast

      • Toasted Turkey Tapenade$12.50

        Arugula, Multi-Grain Bread, Havarti

      • Rare Seared Ahi Sandwich$15.00

        Spinach, Wasabi, Crispy Onion, Sambal Honey, Cilantro, Sesame

      • Smoked Cuban Pulled Pork Melt$12.00

        Jalapenos, Pickles, Cilantro Lime Sour Cream, Toasted Ciabatta

      • Blackened Chicken Sandwich$12.00

        Back by Popular Demand! Smokey Mayo, LTO

      • The Main Dish Burger$12.00

        Hand Pattied, Bacon Onion Jam, Smokey Mayo, Provolone


      Gluten Free Pasta Available Upon Request

      • Smoked Salmon Pesto Gemelli$14.50

        Organic Canadian Salmon, Fresh Basil, Parmesan

      • Buccatini Ala Carbonara$14.50

        Peppadews, Grand Padano, Swiss Chard

      • Bloody Mary Shrimp Angel Hair$17.50

        Roasted Garlic, Pickle, Celery, Sweet Peruvian Peppers

      • Three Cheese Tortellini$15.00

        Prosciutto, Caramelized Onions, Gorgonzola Cream (Add Grilled Breast of Chicken for $5)

      • Tarragon Mushroom Fusilli$13.50

        Foraged Mushrooms, Goat Cheese, Parmesan, Spinach

      • "Steak Bite" Marsala$17.50

        Caramelized with Mushrooms, Fettuccini

      • Classic Chicken Breast Cacciatora$16.50

        "Hunter's" Ragout of Tomatoes, Bacon, Bell Pepper, Mushroom, Fettuccini

      • Spicy Sausage & Chicken Penne$18.00

        Spinach, Bacon, Parmesan, Smoked Sausage, Fennel